Hidden foreign ownership helps explain Metro Vancouver’s ‘decoupling’ of house prices, incomes

Douglas Todd: 

Hidden foreign ownership helps explain Metro Vancouver’s ‘decoupling’ of house prices, incomes

Opinion: ‘Significant sums of foreign capital that have been excluded from official statistics’ behind the disconnect, new peer-reviewed study out of SFU shows

VANCOUVER, BC - September 15, 2019  - David Eby at  home in Vancouver, BC, September 15, 2019. David Eby, Q.C. is a lawyer and Member of the Legislative Assembly of British Columbia, serving as Attorney General. (Arlen Redekop / PNG staff photo) (story by Rob Shaw) [PNG Merlin Archive]B.C. Attorney General David Eby, who has had housing added to his bailiwick, at home in Vancouver last year. In acknowledging the province’s speculation and vacancy tax needs ongoing evaluation, he says ‘this phenomenon of Vancouver being an international city and people being resident here but not earning their income here is one that our tax system is still working to come to terms with.’ PHOTO BY ARLEN REDEKOP /PNG files

Article Sidebar

TRENDING

  1. Nurse losing patience with 'unfair' anti-mask demonstrations in B.C.

  2. Teenager dies in targeted stabbing in east Vancouver

  3. Fraser Health changes school notifications for students, staff over COVID-19

  4. COVID-19: T & T Supermarket at Metrotown in Burnaby reports case

  5. Vancouver real estate: Shift on to big corporate landlords of apartment buildings

    with Video

Article content

The lack of connection between soaring housing prices and tepid local wages in Metro Vancouver is caused in large part by hidden foreign ownership, says a peer-reviewed study from Simon Fraser University that is being welcomed by the B.C. minister responsible for housing.

Based on data Statistics Canada has been collecting only recently, SFU public policy specialist Joshua Gordon’s paper shows the “decoupling” of housing prices from incomes in Metro Vancouver has been caused by “significant sums of foreign capital that have been excluded from official statistics.”

Gordon’s research set out to solve a puzzle in Greater Vancouver and, to a lesser extent, Toronto. How can tens of thousands of owners who tell Revenue Canada they are low income (earning less than $44,000 a year) consistently afford homes valued in the $2- to $10-million range?

The new data revealed Richmond, West Vancouver, the city of Vancouver and Burnaby were epicentres of the foreign-ownership phenomenon: They have the highest housing prices, low average declared incomes and the largest proportions of non-resident owners.

Advertisement

 
STORY CONTINUES BELOW
 
This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below.

Article content continued

“This is a powerful corroboration of the idea that substantial amounts of income are not being declared in satellite family situations,” said Gordon, whose paper defines foreign ownership as “housing purchased primarily with income or wealth earned abroad and not taxed as income in Canada.”

The strange decoupling of housing prices from local wages is peculiar to Metro Vancouver and Greater Toronto. It does not show up in most Canadian cities or in the U.S., Gordon says, where high housing prices invariably correspond with high wages.

Gordon’s study is the first to be based on crucial new data from the Canadian Housing Statistics Program, which for the first time began two years ago to track the extent to which non-residents were buying housing.

SFU professor Josh Gordon. Submitted photo. [PNG Merlin Archive]“The areas (of Metro Vancouver) with the highest rates of foreign ownership are the areas with the greatest decoupling of prices from homeowner incomes,” says new paper by Joshua Gordon, of Simon Fraser University’s School of Public Policy. PHOTO BY SUBMITTED PHOTO /PNG

“This study provides evidence of widespread tax avoidance in certain urban areas,” Gordon says in his paper, titled Solving puzzles in the Canadian housing market: foreign ownership and de-coupling in Toronto and Vancouver, published last month in Housing Studies.

“The evidence suggests that considerable tax avoidance is occurring in satellite family situations,” says Gordon, who appreciates B.C.’s unique speculation and vacancy tax for monitoring such satellite ownership.

MORE ON THIS TOPIC

Richard Wozny, a Vancouver-based commercial property analyst, became acutely aware of the harsh indirect consequences of Metro Vancouver’s real-estate investment boom while being treated for terminal non-smoking lung cancer at Lions Gate Hospital, where he heard about the grim housing struggles of the medical staff.

Richard Wozny: Death, taxes and the terrible injustice of Metro Vancouver's housing crisis

None

Douglas Todd: Why we need to stop subsidizing foreign ownership of Metro housing

More by Douglas Todd

Attorney General David Eby, the minister responsible for housing, welcomed Gordon’s research. “It’s helpful to have work like this, using independent data sets, that positively correlates some of the activity we know is happening in the market.”

Advertisement

 
STORY CONTINUES BELOW
 
This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below.

Article content continued

The B.C. NDP government “didn’t wait for the smoking gun” before it brought in its 2019 speculation tax, the first of its kind anywhere, Eby said. Even while many denied the property market was being distorted, Eby said, “we saw enough to realize foreign capital was a factor. So we took action.”

B.C.’s speculation tax applies a two per cent annual surcharge on homes owned by either foreign citizens or satellite families, which it defines as households where over 50 per cent of income is earned abroad.

Chart reveals a strange Metro Vancouver phenomenon in which the municipalities in which residents report the lowest incomes — Richmond, the city of Vancouver and Burnaby — also have some of the highest housing prices. (Source: SFU’s Joshua Gordon)

While Gordon generally endorsed B.C.’s speculation and vacancy tax, he stressed it must be rigorously enforced — and also suggested it could be strengthened.

Gordon questioned whether it’s wise to exempt homeowners from the speculation tax if they rent out even part of their dwelling. “This rental exemption for single-detached properties might be eliminated entirely … pressuring foreign-sourced owners to either sell into the local market or to pay an annual property surtax.”

Eby, calling the speculation tax “an experiment,” acknowledged it needs ongoing evaluation. “This phenomenon of Vancouver being an international city and people being resident here but not earning their income here is one that our tax system is still working to come to terms with.”

The cohort of more than 200,000 people who were approved entry to Metro Vancouver through Canada’s business immigrant programs, Gordon said, provide one of the most striking illustrations of satellite families who declare almost no income in Canada yet own costly houses.

Advertisement

 
STORY CONTINUES BELOW
 
This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below.

Article content continued

“Migrants arriving with substantial wealth can have a pronounced effect on housing prices” by creating “powerful downstream effects,” says Gordon’s paper, citing the research of Markus Moos and Andrejs Skaburskis, who found almost two out of three investor immigrants to Canada, mostly from Asia, choose to buy property in Metro Vancouver.

An earlier Statistics Canada study found the median value of a detached Vancouver home bought by immigrants who arrived via the investor program was $2.55 million, but the same group “declared an average of only around $20,000 in income in the first 10 years after landing.”

Chart shows that West Vancouver, Vancouver, Richmond and Burnaby have by far the highest gaps between median house prices and average incomes. They are also the municipalities with the largest proportion of non-resident owners. (Source: SFU’s Joshua Gordon)

Gordon’s paper captures how Vancouver condo marketer Bob Rennie, former chief fundraiser for the B.C. Liberal Party, acknowledged the decoupling when he joked in a 2012 speech to the Urban Development Institute that “the Vancouver market never went up on fundamentals, so why would we go down on fundamentals.”

Two of the first public figures to try to flag Metro’s decoupling situation were former Richmond mayor Greg Halsey-Brandt and the one-time head of the Canadian Race Relations Foundation, Albert Lo. They expressed concern in 2015 that the homeowners in Richmond most likely to declare poverty-level incomes (and thus pay low taxes) resided in expensive neighbourhoods. The late housing analyst Richard Wozny also tried to bring attention to how housing “fundamentals” were askew in Metro, with no meaningful link between prices and wages.

Advertisement

 
STORY CONTINUES BELOW
 
This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below.

Article content continued

In the debate over the cause of high housing prices in Canada, Gordon says the conventional explanation, promoted by developers, is that not enough housing supply is being built. But, as Gordon emphasizes, in Canada “there has not been a single peer-reviewed article” exploring the supply theory.

In contrast, Gordon’s paper makes clear “the relationship between foreign ownership and decoupling is very strong and stark: The areas (of Metro Vancouver) with the highest rates of foreign ownership are the areas with the greatest decoupling of prices from homeowner incomes.”

Analysts generally consider housing “affordable” if the ratio of property prices to household income is about four or five to one. But this ratio jumps to a startling 13 to one in Burnaby, 16 to one in Richmond, 22 to one in the city of Vancouver and 23 to one in West Vancouver, which are the municipalities with the highest proportion of non-resident owners.

In Greater Toronto, the municipalities that most follow this same decoupled pattern, Gordon says, are the suburbs of Markham and Richmond Hill.

Eby welcomes how significant new data is now available to shape Canadian tax collectors’ priorities. “I’ve been endlessly frustrated by the proclivity of Revenue Canada to chase small businesses and servers and their tips … instead of being concerned about this phenomenon of people who are very wealthy but who have very low incomes. It undermines public confidence in the tax system of Canada.”

dtodd@postmedia.com

twitter.com/douglastodd

MORE RELATED:

Douglas Todd: Offshore investor of $45 million in Vancouver housing claims fraud

Douglas Todd: U.S. billionaire again battles to stop ‘trespassers’ on his property

SFU prof Don Gutstein spotlighted foreign ownership in Vancouver 30 years ago

CLICK HERE to report a typo.

Is there more to this story? We’d like to hear from you about this or any other stories you think we should know about. Email vantips@postmedia.com.

Comments:
No comments

Post Your Comment:

Categories
The data relating to real estate on this website comes in part from the MLS® Reciprocity program of either the Real Estate Board of Greater Vancouver (REBGV), the Fraser Valley Real Estate Board (FVREB) or the Chilliwack and District Real Estate Board (CADREB). Real estate listings held by participating real estate firms are marked with the MLS® logo and detailed information about the listing includes the name of the listing agent. This representation is based in whole or part on data generated by either the REBGV, the FVREB or the CADREB which assumes no responsibility for its accuracy. The materials contained on this page may not be reproduced without the express written consent of either the REBGV, the FVREB or the CADREB.